Engaging today's political economy
with truth and reason

sponsored by

Mass Shootings and the Problem of Community

05 Aug 2019

I went to bed reading about one mass shooting and woke up hearing about another. Confused, I assumed the coverage was extended, but soon found out the second shooting took place in my geographical backyard. I am in Dayton regularly, though it feels far away from the village I call home. That distance shrank last night when my ten-year-old daughter, who was supposed to be asleep, stumbled into the family room and burst into tears, worried about the shooting. She needed assurance that she was safe. Her life carries the presumption of violence. She has ALICE drills at school, metal detectors and bag searches to get into government buildings, amusement parks, and sporting events, and backpacks built with kevlar inserts. Cold War kids had duck-and-cover drills to prepare for nuclear bombs, but atomic weapons have been used twice in world history. Mass shootings happen with a disconcerting regularity. Unbelievably, her fear did not even feel misplaced.

The policy arguments are well-worn, but I am all ears regardless. I am open to reasonable regulations in light of Second Amendment protections. I am open to better background checks, temporary restraining orders for those manifesting mental and psychological instability, or even a reconsideration of weapon types (though I think this one is much harder given the desire to protect hunters and those who use weapons for self-defense). The political reality is that both sides are dug into their policy positions in such a way that policy IS NOT THE SOLUTION. Unless the dynamics change, the policy debate is intransigent. Howling at public officials, even when the howls are justified and born out of tragic loss, has not worked.

Here is the cold, hard truth. We, The People, may need to consider what we can do on our own. Here is a short, ill-considered list.

I don’t suffer any illusion these things are easy or, even if implemented, they would cure the problem. I am also not pretending these are unique or original ideas. But I am convinced that our culture is producing too many people willing to murder in the name of a twisted ideology, or because they feel aggrieved and cast out from society. We have to work on people because the policy solutions, even if they exist, aren’t coming any time soon.